{ "schemaVersion": 1, "generatedAt": "2026-08-20T00:00:00.000Z", "comparisons": [ { "resourceId": "tools-translation-management-systems", "criteria": [ { "id": "deployment", "label": "Where it runs & where data goes" }, { "id": "commercial", "label": "How it is sold" }, { "id": "developer-flow", "label": "Code, API & automation" }, { "id": "content", "label": "Content it handles" }, { "id": "linguistic-assets", "label": "Memory & terminology" }, { "id": "review-context", "label": "Review & context" }, { "id": "quality-ai", "label": "Quality, MT & AI" }, { "id": "portability", "label": "How you get your data out" } ], "views": [ { "id": "shortlist", "label": "Shortlist", "criteria": [ "deployment", "commercial", "content", "review-context", "portability" ] }, { "id": "workflow", "label": "Workflow", "criteria": [ "content", "linguistic-assets", "review-context", "quality-ai" ] }, { "id": "governance", "label": "Integration & governance", "criteria": [ "deployment", "developer-flow", "quality-ai", "portability" ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "All evidence", "criteria": [] } ], "products": [ { "id": "phrase", "name": "Phrase", "website": "https://phrase.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; public plan structure with enterprise sales path.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "API, CLI, webhooks, and GitHub, GitLab, and Bitbucket sync.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software, document, design, and content workflows with broad format support.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and term bases.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Workflow review, screenshots, in-context editor, and design integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automated QA plus configurable MT and AI-assisted workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API, CLI, file downloads, and linguistic-resource export workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "phrase-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "lokalise", "name": "Lokalise", "website": "https://lokalise.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; public plans and enterprise sales path.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "REST API, SDKs, webhooks, CLI, and repository apps.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software, document, design-file, and content workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and glossaries.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Review states, screenshots, comments, and design-tool context.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automated checks, MT, and AI features with workspace controls.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API and file downloads; verify bulk asset and history export in the target plan.", "sourceIds": [ "lokalise-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "crowdin", "name": "Crowdin", "website": "https://crowdin.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted Crowdin and a separate Enterprise product.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; public plan information.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "REST API, CLI, webhooks, repository integrations, and configuration files.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Extensive software and content format support.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and glossaries.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Proofreading, issues, screenshots, and in-context localization.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "QA checks plus MT and AI provider integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API, CLI, builds, file downloads, TM, and glossary exports.", "sourceIds": [ "crowdin-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "smartling", "name": "Smartling", "website": "https://www.smartling.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; pricing is sales-led.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "API, webhook subscriptions, connectors, and a hosted GitHub connector.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software, websites, documents, and connector-driven content.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory, glossary, and terminology workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Visual context, issues, and configurable review workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Quality checks plus machine-translation and AI workflow products.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API, connector, and file retrieval; validate a full program export during procurement.", "sourceIds": [ "smartling-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "transifex", "name": "Transifex", "website": "https://www.transifex.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; public plan information.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "API, CLI, webhooks, GitHub integration, and CI-compatible workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software, website, and content localization.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and glossaries.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Review workflow plus live and visual context.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Translation checks, MT, and AI-assisted translation.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API, CLI, and file downloads; verify history and linguistic-asset exit needs.", "sourceIds": [ "transifex-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "memoq-tms", "name": "memoQ TMS", "website": "https://www.memoq.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Customer-managed server and hosted-service options.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; server and hosted terms are quote-based.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "Automation and web-service interfaces; repository sync is not a primary workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Broad translation, localization, and document formats.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Server translation memories, term bases, LiveDocs, and shared resources.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Workflow states, web/desktop review, and format-dependent previews.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "QA settings, reports, MT plugins, and workflow configuration.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Project packages, bilingual files, TMX, TBX, and resource export.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-tms-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "weblate", "name": "Weblate", "website": "https://weblate.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Self-hosted open-source software or hosted Weblate.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Copyleft open-source core; paid hosting and support.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "VCS-native workflow, REST API, webhooks, and continuous localization.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software localization formats centered on repository-managed files.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory, glossary, and terminology checks.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Browser translation, review states, comments, screenshots, and source links.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automated checks, suggestions, and configurable machine-translation services.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Translations remain in version control; API, file, TMX, and glossary export are documented.", "sourceIds": [ "weblate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "tolgee", "name": "Tolgee", "website": "https://tolgee.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Open-source self-hosting and vendor-hosted cloud.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open-source platform with commercial cloud and enterprise tiers.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "SDKs, CLI, REST API, webhooks, and content delivery.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Application strings and supported import/export formats; strongest fit is software localization.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and glossary features.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "In-context editing, screenshots, comments, and review states.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Machine translation and AI translation with edition-dependent controls.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API, CLI, and file export; self-hosting provides an additional exit path.", "sourceIds": [ "tolgee-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "xtm-cloud", "name": "XTM Cloud", "website": "https://xtm.cloud/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted enterprise cloud platform.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; sales-led pricing.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "API and connectors; exact automation entitlement is plan-dependent.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Enterprise document, software, CMS, and connector workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memories and terminology shared across workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Browser workbench, workflow roles, comments, and format-dependent context.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "QA profiles, MT, and AI-assisted workflow capabilities.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Bilingual files and linguistic-resource exports; require an exit rehearsal for connected content.", "sourceIds": [ "xtm-cloud-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "localazy", "name": "Localazy", "website": "https://localazy.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary service with public plans.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "CLI, API, webhooks, integrations, and repository-friendly automation.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Application, mobile, web, and structured localization files.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and glossary workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Browser translation and review with source-key context.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automated checks, machine translation, and assisted translation.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "CLI, API, and file export keep application resources recoverable.", "sourceIds": [ "localazy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "poeditor", "name": "POEditor", "website": "https://poeditor.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary with public plan information and feature limits.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "REST API, webhooks, and repository integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software-localization formats centered on terms, keys, and language files.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory and terminology features; availability can depend on plan.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Contributor roles, comments, reference language, and browser review.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automated translation and project checks; verify provider and review controls.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "API and project exports; rehearse terms, translations, contributors, and linguistic assets.", "sourceIds": [ "poeditor-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "simplelocalize", "name": "SimpleLocalize", "website": "https://simplelocalize.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS with translation hosting.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary service with public plans.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "CLI, REST API, GitHub App, webhooks, IDE extensions, and an MCP server.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Application and structured localization files with documented import and export formats.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory, keys, tags, and project terminology workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Browser editor, comments, key metadata, acceptance state, and repository checks.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Automations, machine translation, AI features, limits, and hard-coded-string checks.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "CLI, API, repository sync, file download, and CDN publishing; export project assets before selection.", "sourceIds": [ "simplelocalize-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "lingohub", "name": "LingoHub", "website": "https://lingohub.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary with public plan information and enterprise options.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "developer-flow", "value": "Repository connections, API, CLI-oriented workflows, webhooks, and integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "content", "value": "Software, mobile, web, and structured localization formats.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory, glossary, and style-guide features.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "review-context", "value": "Browser editor, workflow statuses, context, and collaboration.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality-ai", "value": "Quality checks, machine translation, and AI-supported workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "File export plus TMX or CSV translation-memory export; verify history and project-wide exit needs.", "sourceIds": [ "lingohub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] } ] }, { "resourceId": "tools-developer-i18n-frameworks", "criteria": [ { "id": "runtime", "label": "Runtime & framework fit" }, { "id": "message-model", "label": "Message model" }, { "id": "extraction", "label": "Extraction & catalogs" }, { "id": "type-safety", "label": "Type safety & validation" }, { "id": "routing-ssr", "label": "Routing, SSR & locale isolation" }, { "id": "rich-text", "label": "Rich text & translator control" }, { "id": "fallback", "label": "Fallback & missing messages" }, { "id": "portability", "label": "Catalog portability" } ], "views": [ { "id": "shortlist", "label": "Shortlist", "criteria": [ "runtime", "message-model", "type-safety", "routing-ssr", "portability" ] }, { "id": "workflow", "label": "Workflow", "criteria": [ "message-model", "extraction", "rich-text", "fallback" ] }, { "id": "governance", "label": "Integration & governance", "criteria": [ "type-safety", "routing-ssr", "fallback", "portability" ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "All evidence", "criteria": [] } ], "products": [ { "id": "formatjs", "name": "FormatJS / React Intl", "website": "https://formatjs.github.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "JavaScript libraries and build tooling; React bindings are first-class.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "ICU MessageFormat with plural, select, number, and date formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "CLI/Babel/TypeScript extraction and compiled-message workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "TypeScript APIs plus extraction and compile validation; IDs are not generated typed functions by default.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Formatting supports SSR; routing and request locale isolation belong to the application.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Rich-text placeholders map tags to application components.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Default messages and runtime error handling are configurable.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "JSON and custom formatter outputs; ICU messages are broadly interoperable.", "sourceIds": [ "formatjs-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "i18next", "name": "i18next", "website": "https://www.i18next.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Runtime library with browser, server, mobile, and framework adapters.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Keyed resources, interpolation, plural/context variants, and plugin-based ICU support.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Resource files and ecosystem tooling; no single mandatory extraction workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "TypeScript resource augmentation can type keys; plugin choices affect coverage.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Framework adapters and detectors; applications must isolate server request state.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Framework wrappers map message markup to components.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Fallback languages, namespaces, missing-key hooks, and save-missing behavior.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Application-controlled JSON and plugin-defined formats.", "sourceIds": [ "i18next-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "lingui", "name": "Lingui", "website": "https://lingui.dev/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "JavaScript/TypeScript runtime, React integration, compiler, and CLI.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "ICU-style messages through macros and components.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Source extraction into PO or configured catalogs, then compilation.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Macros validate message syntax and variables; catalog typing is not the primary contract.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Supports SSR; routing and per-request activation remain application concerns.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Components and macros preserve rich-text structure.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Catalog activation and fallback are application-configured.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "PO-centered workflows and configurable catalog formats.", "sourceIds": [ "lingui-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "vue-i18n", "name": "Vue I18n", "website": "https://vue-i18n.intlify.dev/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Vue plugin with Composition and legacy APIs.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Keyed messages, pluralization, linked messages, and custom formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "JSON/YAML resources and ecosystem tooling; no single required extractor.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "TypeScript schemas can type messages; coverage depends on configuration.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "SSR is supported; Vue/router integration establishes locale and isolation.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Translation component interpolates components without raw HTML.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Locale chains, fallback settings, and missing/fallback warnings.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Application-controlled JSON/YAML resources.", "sourceIds": [ "vue-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "angular-i18n", "name": "Angular i18n", "website": "https://angular.dev/guide/i18n", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Angular compiler localization plus runtime $localize APIs.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Template messages with meaning, descriptions, IDs, and ICU expressions.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "CLI extraction and localized builds using XLIFF or supported formats.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Compiler validates templates and translation structure; IDs are not typed application functions.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Build-time locale deployments and application routing follow Angular architecture.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Template messages preserve component and element structure.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Missing-translation behavior is build-configurable; fallback is deployment-driven.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "XLIFF and other extraction formats are repository-controlled.", "sourceIds": [ "angular-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "next-intl", "name": "next-intl", "website": "https://next-intl.dev/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Next.js toolkit for App Router and Pages Router.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "ICU messages plus date, number, list, and display-name formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "JSON messages with extraction and integration workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "TypeScript augmentation can type locales, messages, formats, and arguments.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Localized routing, middleware, Server Components, and request configuration are first-class.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Rich-text messages map tags to React elements.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Application-defined message loading and error/fallback handling.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "JSON catalogs remain application-controlled; routing is next-intl-specific.", "sourceIds": [ "next-intl-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "fluent", "name": "Project Fluent", "website": "https://projectfluent.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Open specification with JavaScript, Python, Rust, and React implementations.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "FTL supports asymmetric translations, selectors, terms, attributes, and locale-specific variants.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "FTL resources are normally authored directly; extraction depends on the host integration.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Syntax parsers validate resources; generated application types are not the core model.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Runtime retranslation is supported; routing and request isolation belong to the host.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Overlay patterns let translations control safe text structure.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Implementations expose fallback and robust error handling.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "FTL is open text, with less commercial-tool support than JSON, PO, or XLIFF.", "sourceIds": [ "fluent-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "paraglide", "name": "Paraglide JS", "website": "https://paraglidejs.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Compiler-first ESM functions for Vite, React, SvelteKit, Vue, Astro, routers, and vanilla JS/TS.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Typed functions with variants and locale formatters; ICU and other formats are plugin-backed.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Compiles version-controlled inlang projects and message files into generated modules.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Generated functions type message keys and parameters.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Localized URL strategies, middleware, SSR, and request-scoped locale handling.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Typed markup adapters keep components in application control.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Compile/runtime errors and locale strategies are explicit; dynamic keys are a constrained fit.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "Version-controlled files with plugin paths for JSON, i18next, XLIFF, and ICU.", "sourceIds": [ "paraglide-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "django", "name": "Django i18n", "website": "https://docs.djangoproject.com/en/6.0/topics/i18n/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Built into the Django Python web framework.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "GNU gettext messages with singular, plural, context, and lazy translation APIs.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "makemessages extracts translatable strings; compilemessages builds binary catalogs.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "String-based message identifiers; extraction and compilation catch syntax but do not create typed application calls.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "LocaleMiddleware and request-language selection fit server-rendered applications.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Template block translation supports variables and controlled markup; application escaping still matters.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Django and gettext locale fallback behavior depends on active language and catalog availability.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "PO and MO catalogs use established gettext tooling.", "sourceIds": [ "django-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "rails", "name": "Rails I18n", "website": "https://guides.rubyonrails.org/i18n.html", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Built into Ruby on Rails through the Ruby I18n API.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Keyed translations, interpolation, pluralization, date and number formats, and replaceable backends.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Locale dictionaries are normally maintained in YAML or Ruby; extraction relies on ecosystem tooling.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "String or symbol keys are not typed by the framework.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Per-request locale patterns and I18n.with_locale are documented; applications own routing and isolation.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "HTML-safe key conventions exist, so source trust and escaping rules require care.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Default locale and backend fallback can be configured.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "YAML and Ruby catalogs are application-controlled; interchange may require conversion.", "sourceIds": [ "rails-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "laravel", "name": "Laravel localization", "website": "https://laravel.com/docs/12.x/localization", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Built into the Laravel PHP framework.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "Short keyed PHP files or JSON strings with replacement and pluralization.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Language files can be published; no single built-in source extractor defines the workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "String keys are not typed by the framework.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Applications can set and inspect locale per request and configure a fallback locale.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Messages are strings; safe markup and component structure remain application concerns.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Application locale and fallback locale are explicit configuration.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "PHP arrays and JSON remain in the application repository.", "sourceIds": [ "laravel-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "flutter", "name": "Flutter gen_l10n", "website": "https://docs.flutter.dev/ui/internationalization", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Flutter and Dart applications across mobile, desktop, and web.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "ARB resources support parameters, plurals, selects, and locale metadata through intl tooling.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "The gen_l10n workflow generates localization classes from ARB catalogs; source discovery is application-managed.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Generated Dart accessors provide typed parameters for declared messages.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "Locale resolution and supported locales are first-class; web routing remains application architecture.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Generated messages return text; rich component composition stays in Dart code.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Supported-locale resolution and a configured default govern fallback.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "ARB is version-controlled JSON with ICU-style metadata and broad TMS support.", "sourceIds": [ "flutter-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "android", "name": "Android resources", "website": "https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/resources/localization", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Native Android views and Jetpack Compose through the platform resource system.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "String, string-array, and quantity resources with format arguments and locale qualifiers.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Resources live in values directories and are compiled by Android build tooling.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Generated resource identifiers are compile-time symbols; format-argument compatibility still needs testing.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "The platform selects resources by device and app locale; there is no server-rendering model.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "Styled strings and application composition are supported within platform constraints.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "A complete default resource set is mandatory; Android applies qualifier precedence.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "XML resources are repository-controlled and commonly exchanged with localization platforms.", "sourceIds": [ "android-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "apple-string-catalogs", "name": "Apple String Catalogs", "website": "https://developer.apple.com/localization/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Apple-platform applications built with Xcode, SwiftUI, UIKit, or AppKit.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "String Catalogs support variables, plurals, device variants, comments, state, and locale variants.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "Xcode discovers strings from localizable APIs during builds and maintains XCStrings catalogs.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Localizable symbols can reduce string-literal use; coverage depends on project configuration and APIs.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "App and system language selection are platform-managed; no SSR model.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "SwiftUI and attributed-string composition remain in application code with localized resources.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": "Development language and bundle lookup govern missing localization behavior.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "XCStrings are repository files; Xcode can export and import XLIFF localization catalogs.", "sourceIds": [ "apple-string-catalog-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "aspnet-core", "name": "ASP.NET Core localization", "website": "https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/aspnet/core/fundamentals/localization", "values": [ { "criterionId": "runtime", "value": "Server-rendered and API applications on ASP.NET Core.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "message-model", "value": "IStringLocalizer, IHtmlLocalizer, view localization, data-annotation messages, and culture-aware formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "extraction", "value": "RESX resources and build tooling are the standard catalog path; source extraction is project-dependent.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "type-safety", "value": "Localizer access is often string-keyed; strongly typed ResourceManager patterns can be added.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "routing-ssr", "value": "RequestLocalizationMiddleware selects culture from configured providers per request.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "rich-text", "value": "IHtmlLocalizer supports localized HTML while encoding parameters; source-resource trust remains important.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "fallback", "value": ".NET resource lookup uses culture and parent-culture fallback under configured supported cultures.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "portability", "value": "RESX is repository-controlled XML with common localization-tool support.", "sourceIds": [ "dotnet-i18n-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] } ] }, { "resourceId": "tools-cat-terminology-qa", "criteria": [ { "id": "platform", "label": "Platform & operating model" }, { "id": "commercial", "label": "Commercial model" }, { "id": "formats", "label": "Production formats" }, { "id": "linguistic-assets", "label": "TM, terminology & concordance" }, { "id": "qa", "label": "Linguistic & technical QA" }, { "id": "context", "label": "Preview & review context" }, { "id": "automation-ai", "label": "Automation, MT & AI" }, { "id": "interchange", "label": "Packages, reports & interchange" } ], "views": [ { "id": "shortlist", "label": "Shortlist", "criteria": [ "platform", "commercial", "formats", "qa", "interchange" ] }, { "id": "workflow", "label": "Workflow", "criteria": [ "formats", "linguistic-assets", "qa", "context" ] }, { "id": "governance", "label": "Integration & governance", "criteria": [ "platform", "automation-ai", "interchange" ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "All evidence", "criteria": [] } ], "products": [ { "id": "trados-studio", "name": "Trados Studio", "website": "https://www.trados.com/products/trados-studio/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop CAT application with connected cloud services.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary editions and subscriptions.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Broad document, software, bilingual, and package support.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memories, MultiTerm terminology, concordance, and alignment.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Verification profiles cover terminology, consistency, tags, numbers, and formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Bilingual editor plus format-dependent previews.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "SDK, batch tasks, MT providers, and generative translation capabilities.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "SDLXLIFF, project packages, target files, TMX, and termbase exchange.", "sourceIds": [ "trados-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "memoq-translator", "name": "memoQ translator pro", "website": "https://www.memoq.com/memoq-translator-pro/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop CAT application with optional server/cloud collaboration.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary perpetual or subscription paths.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Broad document, software, package, and bilingual formats.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memories, term bases, LiveDocs, alignment, and concordance.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Configurable terminology, tag, consistency, and number checks.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Translation grid, comments, and format-dependent previews.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Templates, automation interfaces, MT plugins, and AI integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "MQXLIFF, packages, targets, TMX, TBX, and resource export.", "sourceIds": [ "memoq-desktop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "omegat", "name": "OmegaT", "website": "https://omegat.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Cross-platform desktop application.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open source with no license fee.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Document and localization formats through file filters.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "TMX memories, glossaries, dictionaries, concordance, and team assets.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Tag validation, spelling, and consistency-oriented checks.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Segment context and format-dependent target review.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Scripts, plugins, team projects, and MT connectors.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "TMX, glossary files, projects, and generated targets.", "sourceIds": [ "omegat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "wordfast-pro", "name": "Wordfast Pro", "website": "https://www.wordfast.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Cross-platform desktop CAT application.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary license with public purchase information.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Document and localization formats plus bilingual packages.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Local and remote translation memories and glossaries.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Transcheck covers terminology, consistency, tags, numbers, and formatting.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Bilingual editor and format-dependent preview.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Machine-translation connectors; public automation surface is limited.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Bilingual files, targets, TMX, glossaries, and packages.", "sourceIds": [ "wordfast-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "smartcat", "name": "Smartcat", "website": "https://www.smartcat.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Browser-based collaborative language-delivery platform.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary SaaS with plan-based packaging.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Document, localization, subtitle, and other production formats.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memories, glossaries, search, and shared assets.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Automated checks, review stages, comments, and issues.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Browser editor with file-dependent context and collaboration.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "AI translation, MT, workflow automation, and integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Target and bilingual downloads plus TM and glossary management; rehearse full exit.", "sourceIds": [ "smartcat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "matecat", "name": "MateCat", "website": "https://www.matecat.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Browser CAT tool and open-source server code.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Free hosted use with an open-source codebase; related services are commercial.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Common document and localization formats.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Private and public TM options, glossaries, and concordance.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Tag, number, terminology, and consistency checks with review.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Segment editor and file-dependent preview.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Machine-translation integration and web project automation.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Bilingual files, targets, and TMX download paths.", "sourceIds": [ "matecat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "cafetran", "name": "CafeTran Espresso", "website": "https://www.cafetran.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Cross-platform desktop CAT application.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary trial and subscription/perpetual paths.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Documents, localization files, and external CAT packages.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Local TMs, termbases, glossaries, and concordance.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Tags, spelling, consistency, terminology, and number checks.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Segment context and format-dependent previews.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "MT connectors, automatic assembly, and configurable actions.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "TMX, TBX/glossary, bilingual packages, and targets.", "sourceIds": [ "cafetran-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "xbench", "name": "ApSIC Xbench", "website": "https://www.xbench.net/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop QA, terminology, and search application.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary with free and licensed editions.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Reads many CAT bilingual, memory, and terminology formats.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Cross-project concordance, terminology search, and checklists.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Cross-file consistency, terminology, numeric, tag, and regex checks.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Issue context and navigation back to supported CAT tools.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Command-line automation; no reviewed generative-AI workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "QA reports, checklists, and glossary output; not a full target-file producer.", "sourceIds": [ "xbench-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "qa-distiller", "name": "QA Distiller", "website": "https://www.qa-distiller.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop linguistic QA application.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary licensing.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Multiple bilingual and localization formats.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Cross-file consistency and terminology lists.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Terminology, consistency, numbers, tags, punctuation, and formatting checks.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Issue context within loaded bilingual files.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Batch QA is the focus; no reviewed AI production workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "QA report export; it complements rather than replaces a CAT tool.", "sourceIds": [ "qa-distiller-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "across-translator", "name": "Across Translator Edition", "website": "https://www.across.net/en/service-portfolio/products/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows standalone CAT environment that can also connect to an Across Language Server.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary freelancer edition and server-connected workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Professional document and localization formats handled through Across projects.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "crossTank translation memory and crossTerm terminology.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Configurable checks and terminology control inside the translation workflow.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Editor access to source, matches, terminology, and project information.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Server connections, MT, and Across AI features depend on the deployed product and permissions.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Project packages and standard exchange paths; verify TM, terminology, and target export with the client setup.", "sourceIds": [ "across-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "dejavu", "name": "Déjà Vu X3", "website": "https://dejavux4.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop CAT application.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary perpetual-license product.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Broad document, software, localization, subtitle, and bilingual-format support documented in the user guide.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Translation memory, terminology databases, lexicon, and concordance.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Terminology, consistency, numeric, formatting, and project checks.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Bilingual editor with project, file, and match context.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Batch and automation features plus MT integration; current AI depth is limited in reviewed documentation.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "TMX, XLIFF, external CAT formats, target files, and project assets.", "sourceIds": [ "dejavu-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "transit-nxt", "name": "Transit NXT", "website": "https://www.star-ts.com/software/translation-memory-transit-nxt/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop and networked professional translation environment.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary editions with perpetual and subscription paths.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Document, software-localization, subtitle, project-package, and external bilingual formats.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Reference-file translation memory, TermStar terminology, concordance, and multilingual project reuse.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Terminology, consistency, formatting, and project-quality functions.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Synchronized source-document and translation context is a central design feature.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "Machine-translation connections and batch workflows; verify automation in the selected edition.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Transit packages, XLIFF and external packages, target files, terminology, and reference materials.", "sourceIds": [ "transit-nxt-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "verifika", "name": "Verifika", "website": "https://e-verifika.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Standalone and web/API-oriented linguistic QA product.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary licensing and service offerings.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "formats", "value": "Bilingual files from multiple CAT and localization platforms.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "linguistic-assets", "value": "Terminology lists, word forms, untranslatables, and cross-file analysis.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "qa", "value": "Rule-based checks for terminology, consistency, numbers, punctuation, tags, spelling, and custom requirements.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "context", "value": "Issue lists link findings to translation units and editable context.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation-ai", "value": "QA API supports integration and automation; it is not a full translation-production environment.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "interchange", "value": "Reports, corrected bilingual files, API results, and platform connections; test the exact format round trip.", "sourceIds": [ "verifika-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] } ] }, { "resourceId": "tools-subtitling-audiovisual", "criteria": [ { "id": "platform", "label": "Platform & working mode" }, { "id": "commercial", "label": "Commercial model" }, { "id": "authoring", "label": "Authoring, spotting & translation" }, { "id": "timing-qc", "label": "Timing, reading speed & QC" }, { "id": "accessibility", "label": "Captions & accessibility" }, { "id": "collaboration", "label": "Review & collaboration" }, { "id": "automation", "label": "ASR, MT & automation" }, { "id": "delivery", "label": "Delivery formats & integrations" } ], "views": [ { "id": "shortlist", "label": "Shortlist", "criteria": [ "platform", "commercial", "authoring", "timing-qc", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "workflow", "label": "Workflow", "criteria": [ "authoring", "timing-qc", "accessibility", "collaboration", "automation" ] }, { "id": "governance", "label": "Integration & governance", "criteria": [ "platform", "collaboration", "automation", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "All evidence", "criteria": [] } ], "products": [ { "id": "subtitle-edit", "name": "Subtitle Edit", "website": "https://www.nikse.dk/subtitleedit", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Desktop application, strongest on Windows, with source available.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open source with no license fee.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Grid, waveform, video, translation, synchronization, and batch tools.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Reading-speed, duration, gap, overlap, spelling, and format checks.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Caption formats, hearing-impaired workflows, waveform, and audio visualization.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "File-based handoff; no native hosted review workspace.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Speech recognition, translation, OCR, command-line, and plugins.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Very broad subtitle, caption, broadcast, and text-format import/export.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitle-edit-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "aegisub", "name": "Aegisub", "website": "https://aegisub.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Cross-platform desktop subtitle editor.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open source with no license fee.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Timing, translation, karaoke, styling, and advanced typesetting.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Waveform, visual timing, and script inspection; compliance checks are less turnkey.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Can author caption text, but accessibility workflows are not its primary model.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "File-based collaboration and version control.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Lua automation; no first-party hosted ASR/MT service.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Strong ASS/SSA workflow with additional subtitle import/export.", "sourceIds": [ "aegisub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "ooona", "name": "OOONA", "website": "https://www.ooona.net/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Vendor-hosted professional media-localization platform and tool suite.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; sales-led and product-dependent.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Browser subtitling, translation, dubbing, and media workflows by product.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Dedicated timing, compliance, QC, and conformance products.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Captioning, SDH, and accessibility workflows across the suite.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "Assignments, roles, review, comments, and workflow management.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Speech-enabled and automation products; capability depends on module.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Professional broadcast and streaming formats plus integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "ooona-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "eztitles", "name": "EZTitles", "website": "https://www.eztitles.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop plus server and automation products.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary products with public purchase paths.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Professional subtitle/caption authoring, timing, translation, and layout.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Compliance profiles, timing, reading speed, positioning, and format checks.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Closed captions, SDH, teletext, and accessibility delivery.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "File/package workflow; server products add automation rather than browser review.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Batch/server and speech capabilities vary by product.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Extensive cinema, broadcast, disc, streaming, and caption formats.", "sourceIds": [ "eztitles-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "captionhub", "name": "CaptionHub", "website": "https://www.captionhub.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Vendor-hosted collaborative SaaS.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary with public plans and enterprise path.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Browser transcription, captioning, translation, and timed editing.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Reading-speed, line, timing, and workflow checks.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Caption and subtitle workflows; conventions are team-controlled.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "Assignments, comments, review, approval, and shared video context.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Speech recognition, MT, AI features, API, and integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Caption/subtitle downloads and video-platform integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "captionhub-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "amara", "name": "Amara", "website": "https://amara.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Browser-based captioning and subtitling platform.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Public community service plus commercial team and enterprise offerings.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Create, synchronize, translate, and review subtitles in a web editor.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Timing editor and team review; validate broadcaster-specific checks separately.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Designed for caption and subtitle accessibility programs.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "Teams, assignments, roles, review, and community workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "API and integrations; automatic transcription depends on offering.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Common subtitle downloads, video-platform connections, and API access.", "sourceIds": [ "amara-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "subtitlenext", "name": "SubtitleNEXT", "website": "https://subtitlenext.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Professional desktop and live subtitling software.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary licensing.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Offline/live authoring, translation, spotting, and cue management.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Reading speed, timing, shot change, layout, and rule-based checks.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Closed-caption, SDH, and live accessibility workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "Project/file workflow; connected collaboration depends on setup.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Speech, translation, and automation vary by module and integration.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Professional broadcast, streaming, cinema, and subtitle formats.", "sourceIds": [ "subtitlenext-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "wincaps", "name": "WinCAPS Q4", "website": "https://broadstream.com/wincaps/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows professional subtitling and captioning application.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; sales-led licensing.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Offline preparation, timing, translation, and live-caption support.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Timing, reading, layout, and broadcaster-oriented QC.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Closed captions, teletext, SDH, and broadcast accessibility.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "File and production-system workflow rather than browser review.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Speech/live integrations depend on the deployed BroadStream stack.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Broadcast, caption, subtitle, and professional playout formats.", "sourceIds": [ "wincaps-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "fab-subtitler", "name": "FAB Subtitler", "website": "https://www.fab-online.com/subtitling/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows professional software family for offline, live, broadcast, and automated subtitling.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary modules and licenses with product-specific capabilities.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Subtitle preparation, timing, translation support, live operation, and specialized transmission by edition.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Subtitle checking, timecode, scene-change and format-conversion workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Teletext, DVB, closed-caption, open-subtitle, and live accessibility workflows across the product family.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "Workstation, database, network, and file workflows rather than a browser-first review model.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Watch folders, server transcription, APIs, cloud speech, and configurable AI services depend on edition.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "More than 100 file formats plus broadcast, streaming, disc, digital-cinema, teletext, and DVB paths.", "sourceIds": [ "fab-subtitler-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "spot", "name": "Spot", "website": "https://www.spotsoftware.eu/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "platform", "value": "Windows desktop professional subtitling application.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary rental and lifetime-license paths.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "authoring", "value": "Subtitle creation, translation, timing, formatting, video preview, comments, and keyboard-led editing.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "timing-qc", "value": "Timing, reading, line, positioning, interval, and visual-review functions.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "accessibility", "value": "Closed-caption and positioning workflows are supported; validate the target delivery rules.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "collaboration", "value": "File-based professional workflow rather than a hosted multi-user workspace.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Macros and productivity functions; no reviewed hosted automation API.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "delivery", "value": "Professional subtitle and caption format handling; verify the exact broadcaster or platform format in the current edition.", "sourceIds": [ "spot-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] } ] }, { "resourceId": "tools-speech-annotation-evaluation", "criteria": [ { "id": "deployment", "label": "Deployment & data boundary" }, { "id": "commercial", "label": "Commercial model" }, { "id": "modalities", "label": "Modalities & task types" }, { "id": "schema", "label": "Schema & annotation control" }, { "id": "automation", "label": "Model-assisted labeling" }, { "id": "quality", "label": "Review, agreement & adjudication" }, { "id": "integration", "label": "API, SDK & pipeline fit" }, { "id": "export", "label": "Export & dataset portability" } ], "views": [ { "id": "shortlist", "label": "Shortlist", "criteria": [ "deployment", "commercial", "modalities", "quality", "export" ] }, { "id": "workflow", "label": "Workflow", "criteria": [ "modalities", "schema", "automation", "quality" ] }, { "id": "governance", "label": "Integration & governance", "criteria": [ "deployment", "integration", "quality", "export" ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "All evidence", "criteria": [] } ], "products": [ { "id": "label-studio", "name": "Label Studio", "website": "https://labelstud.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Open-source self-hosting plus commercial cloud and enterprise.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open-source core with commercial editions.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Text, audio, image, video, time series, and configurable multimodal tasks.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Labeling configuration defines interfaces, labels, relations, and behavior.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "ML backends, predictions, pre-annotations, and active-learning integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Review and agreement workflows; advanced controls vary by edition.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "REST API, SDK, webhooks, cloud storage, and ML backend interface.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "JSON plus converter formats; preserve labeling configuration with data.", "sourceIds": [ "label-studio-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "argilla", "name": "Argilla", "website": "https://argilla.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Self-hosted open-source server with managed/commercial offerings.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open-source platform with commercial services.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Text-focused feedback datasets for classification, ranking, generation, and extraction.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Typed fields, questions, suggestions, responses, metadata, and vectors.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Model suggestions and programmatic datasets support feedback loops.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Multi-user responses, status, filtering, and analysis; design adjudication explicitly.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Python SDK and model/data ecosystem integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "SDK-based export and Hugging Face-oriented workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "argilla-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "prodigy", "name": "Prodigy", "website": "https://prodi.gy/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Locally run annotation application and Python workflow library.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary per-seat license.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Text, image, audio, video, span, relation, choice, and custom interfaces.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Recipe-driven tasks and JSONL records expose the annotation contract.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Model-in-the-loop recipes, active learning, pre-annotation, and custom Python.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Sessions, review recipes, and agreement analysis require explicit setup.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Python APIs, recipes, databases, web app, and spaCy integration.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "JSONL and application-controlled databases keep raw annotations portable.", "sourceIds": [ "prodigy-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "elan", "name": "ELAN", "website": "https://archive.mpi.nl/tla/elan", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Cross-platform desktop research application.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Free software from the Max Planck Institute.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Audio/video annotation with aligned hierarchical time tiers.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Controlled vocabularies, linguistic types, tier constraints, and participants.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Recognizers and integrations exist; manual expert annotation remains central.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Comparison is possible; adjudication is file/process-driven.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "File interchange and recognizer/tool workflows rather than a hosted API.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "EAF plus tabular, text, subtitle, Praat, and research formats.", "sourceIds": [ "elan-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "cvat", "name": "CVAT", "website": "https://www.cvat.ai/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Open-source self-hosting plus CVAT Online and enterprise.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open-source core with commercial products.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Image/video vision tasks with boxes, polygons, masks, tracks, and skeletons.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Project/task labels, attributes, shapes, tracks, and frame controls.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Automatic annotation, model functions, trackers, and serverless integration.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Review, issues, consensus, honeypots, and analytics vary by edition.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "REST API, SDK, CLI, cloud storage, and model integration.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "Many computer-vision formats plus backups; audio/text are not primary.", "sourceIds": [ "cvat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "doccano", "name": "doccano", "website": "https://doccano.github.io/doccano/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Open-source self-hosted web application.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open source with no license fee.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Text classification, sequence labeling, and sequence-to-sequence.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Projects define label sets and task type; metadata and examples are imported.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Automatic labeling can connect through APIs and clients.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Roles and collaboration; agreement/adjudication depth is limited.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "REST API and client library support import and automation.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "JSONL, CSV, and task-specific formats.", "sourceIds": [ "doccano-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "inception", "name": "INCEpTION", "website": "https://inception-project.github.io/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Open-source self-hosted web application.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Open source with no license fee.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Text annotation for spans, relations, chains, syntax, semantics, and custom layers.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Configurable layers, features, tagsets, constraints, and roles.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Recommenders provide machine assistance and external-model integration.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Curation, agreement, monitoring, and project workflows are first-class.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Formats, recommenders, and remote APIs support research pipelines.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "UIMA CAS/XMI and NLP formats; test custom-layer interoperability.", "sourceIds": [ "inception-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "praat", "name": "Praat", "website": "https://www.praat.org/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Cross-platform desktop application with scripting and batch use.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Free software.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Speech audio analysis, segmentation, transcription, and TextGrid annotation.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Interval and point tiers; teams define conventions externally.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Rich scripting for analysis, segmentation, measurements, and batches.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "No hosted review workflow; quality is script- and protocol-driven.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Command-line and Praat scripting integrate with research pipelines.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "TextGrid, tables, audio, measurements, and generated data are portable.", "sourceIds": [ "praat-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "labelbox", "name": "Labelbox", "website": "https://labelbox.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted data-labeling platform with enterprise controls.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary; plan and service pricing.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Image, video, text, documents, audio, geospatial, and evaluation workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Ontologies define classifications, objects, relations, and reusable structure.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Model-assisted labeling, pre-labels, embeddings, and automation.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Review, consensus, benchmarking, issues, and workforce quality.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "SDKs, APIs, webhooks, cloud data, and model/data pipelines.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "Programmatic exports; rehearse ontology, metadata, and annotation export together.", "sourceIds": [ "labelbox-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "superannotate", "name": "SuperAnnotate", "website": "https://www.superannotate.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted data and evaluation platform with external-storage workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary platform and services.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Multimodal annotation, curation, and generative-AI data workflows; confirm the editor needed for the task.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Project components and workflow configuration define the collection interface and records.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "SDK and AI-pipeline integration support pre-processing, curation, and model-assisted work.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Collaborative review and project controls; design independent adjudication for multilingual judgments.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Python SDK, APIs, external storage, and AI-pipeline integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "Project downloads and structured exports; CSV has documented limits for complex component values.", "sourceIds": [ "superannotate-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "encord", "name": "Encord", "website": "https://encord.com/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted platform with private-cloud data integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary platform and enterprise plans.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Image, video, image-sequence, document, and audio annotation workflows.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Ontologies, classifications, objects, attributes, metadata, and configurable editor layouts.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Automated labeling, model predictions, catalog agents, and custom agent endpoints.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Multi-stage review, edit review, issues, label versions, and event-based analytics.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "SDK, API, webhooks, cloud integrations, and model endpoints.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "Versioned JSON or COCO exports with review and label metadata; rehearse full-fidelity export for the chosen modality.", "sourceIds": [ "encord-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] }, { "id": "dataloop", "name": "Dataloop", "website": "https://dataloop.ai/", "values": [ { "criterionId": "deployment", "value": "Vendor-hosted data platform with cloud-storage and enterprise integration options.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "commercial", "value": "Proprietary platform and services.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "modalities", "value": "Image, video, text, audio, and configurable data-labeling pipelines.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "schema", "value": "Ontologies, labels, attributes, metadata, recipes, and task configuration.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "automation", "value": "Model-assisted annotation, pipelines, SDK automation, and application integrations.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "quality", "value": "Assignments, review tasks, consensus and analytics depend on workflow configuration.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "integration", "value": "Python and JavaScript SDKs, APIs, webhooks, storage, models, and pipelines.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" }, { "criterionId": "export", "value": "Annotation Studio and SDK export paths; validate ontology, metadata, media references, and target format together.", "sourceIds": [ "dataloop-docs" ], "verified": "2026-08-20" } ] } ] } ] }